Home / Technology / PS5 or Xbox Series X? Which next generation consoles are we buying and why

PS5 or Xbox Series X? Which next generation consoles are we buying and why


We are extremely close to next generation consoles and are thrilled! The Xbox Series X is S Series launches on November 10th PlayStation 5 it hits stores two days later, on November 1


But which one should you buy? Which can he do you buy now that pre-orders are out the window?

This is a complicated question with many layers to dissect. The answer is, of course, this It depends. You have a file 4K TV? Do you sign up for Game Pass? You are a Alone fan or a God of war fan? Do you like Bethesda or Naughty Dog games?

We thought we’d ask dedicated players on the CNET staff which consoles they plan to buy and in what order.

Mark Serrels


If you have a 4K TV, you will most likely want to go with the X series over the S series.


I’ve thought about it for a long time and I’m pretty sure I’ll end up with an Xbox Series X and a PlayStation 5.

As the owner of a 4K LG OLED, I have no interest in Xbox Series S, although I like the design. The fact that the console doesn’t support 4K gaming guarantees instead that I’ll be picking up an X series.

I suspect the X series will be the best choice for cross-platform games of this generation and Game Pass is an incredible service, so for me an Xbox Series X is a must. I love the way it smoothly runs last-gen games at sky-high frame rates at 4K. It will take some time for the must-see next-generation titles to arrive, so that’s another major selling point for me.

I will also take a PS5, probably the digital edition. I haven’t bought a boxed copy of a video game in years, despite being slightly cheaper here in Australia. I like the convenience of having all my games stored on one hard drive and I like the lower cost of the digital edition itself.

Which console will I buy first? It depends on which one I can be honest. I will most likely pick up the PS5 if I can, simply because I want to play Demon souls remake. But I’ll get an Xbox Series X at the same time or right after.

Steph Panecasio

I think at this point I have decided to get the digital edition of the Playstation 5, but not at launch. The hype is pretty broad and I like being a spectator of the console war drama, but I’d rather wait until it’s actually needed to get them – my PS4 and Xbox One X can still do the job pretty well and I haven’t still reason to upgrade.

So yes, when I do, I will opt for the Playstation first. Historically I would have both, but I need to stop being an accumulator when it comes to consoles and games (you’re looking at the person who inexplicably has seven physical copies of The Witcher 3).

By opting for just one console (at least to start) I’m saving a huge chunk of space on my TV cabinet – have you seen the size of these things? And by opting for the digital model, I’m freeing up space on my shelves for, well, actual books.

As for Xbox, I’m still incredibly tempted by the Game Pass service, I will not lie. Will I eventually get one? Could be. I almost hope my partner gets one himself, thus eliminating the need for me to worry about shelling out more money. Excuse me as I send you this article for future reference.

Dan Ackerman


CD Project Red

Who am I kidding, I take them both. I’ve already pre-ordered an Xbox Series X and plan on getting a PS5 soon. I can legitimately say it’s for “professional development”, plus, as awful as it sounds, I just like to go through all the menus and configuration and output options and all. This is what happens after working at CNET for a number of years.

Oddly, as a kid I never liked console games. After the Atari 2600, I was right on my Tandy TRS-80 (aka Trash 80) color computer, and mostly on PC gaming during my teenage and college years, but not much of that either. My return to consolation began when I saw a live-action TV commercial for Resident Evil 2 in the late 90’s and said, “Wow, it looks like a George Romero movie, I have to get one …” Less than a year later, I was working on one of the first video game websites (UGO.com) and covering the launch of Sega Dreamcast, so I’ve had every console ever since, from the RROD Xbox 360 to the dusty Wii U.

I’m skipping the S series, there’s no need for that with my LG 4K OLED TV (arguably the most common TV among CNET editors), and frankly, I’m not thrilled with the game’s launch lineup on either console. No must-have for me, and there’s not even a next-generation version of Cyberpunk 2077. I’d love to have my Spider-Man save carried over to PS5, but that’s what backwards compatibility matters to me. I generally have no interest in revisiting old games. They are never as good as you remember. If you’re worried about playing Perfect Dark or Halo 1 or something on a new console for 2020, you might as well take the full leap and start playing Gloomhaven.

Nicole Archer


Horizon Forbidden West will be a must have game on PS5.


I’ll make it short and sweet: I’m not a fan of brutalism and find the Xbox Series X design personally offensive. If my niece comes to see me, I should childproof the box to prevent it from falling and blinded in the corner. Also, I really like Horizon Zero Dawn a lot and want to play the sequel.

That said, I’ll probably have the Xbox Series S eventually because I feel it would look good next to my PS5. Also, my first game console was the original Xbox and I’ll always have a soft spot for the old – I’d betray my roots if I didn’t get an Xbox back in my hand.

Daniel Van Boom

Eventually, I will buy both a PlayStation 5 and an Xbox Series X. By the end of 2020? I didn’t buy either of them.

I enjoy system wars as much as the next, but right now the excitement for both next-gen consoles is a little too theoretical. Microsoft’s Game Pass-centric model, where the S / X series are essentially hardware to power the Xbox streaming service, could change the industry. Sony’s renewed fanaticism over exclusive titles could translate into more must-see first party games.

But both possibilities lie in 2021 and beyond. In November, there won’t be many games on both consoles that you can’t play on PS4 or Xbox One. For me, that means there’s no rush to buy a PS5 or Xbox Series S / X.

For the future, I suspect I’ll buy a PS5 first. Both consoles will be purchased with a hard drive – it’ll be easier to wiggle from an MSRP of $ 69.95.

Lori Grunin

Let’s divide “Lori Grunin” in two: the reviewer and the real person. They both ended up agreeing that Xbox Series S is the best option because of the money and Game Pass Ultimate.


Dan Ackerman / CNET

Personally, a console competes with the need for a new expensive phone, a new iPad Pro, and a new full-frame camera and lens, along with a cranky old biddy of a cat who needs dental work and has expensive taste. in food. I still have a 1080p TV, which I haven’t watched since I cut the cable some time ago. I don’t particularly want to be part of it for a new one because I’m a cranky old curmudgeon of someone with an expensive taste in tools.

While Lori, the reviewer, played with the idea of ​​a PS5, Game Pass Ultimate and the availability of new exclusives on day one sold the Xbox to both sides of my brain.

But I would never pre-order anything, because as a rule I consider it insane to spend money on almost anything over $ 50 before it’s been out for at least a few months and had a chance to be debugged and dissected ad nauseum. I’ve also had years of exposure to the latest and greatest things to learn how to overcome FOMO for most of it.

Lori, the reviewer, spent hours updating on three different sites for everyone when the pre-orders went out.

Jackson Ryan

I’d love to see a new generation of consoles defined by the unique experiences it can deliver to video games, rather than the improvements in POWER and SPEED. These new consoles look current rigged.

I have a fully functional Nintendo Switch. This will help me as long as there is absolutely no play on one of these bilious boxes.

Sean Keane

After thinking about it for a long time, I pre-ordered a PS5 so I could play the brightest version of Marvel’s Spider-Man: Miles Morales and the Demon’s Souls remake. But the deciding factor was Resident Evil Village. I know the console won’t take a price drop before it comes out next year (Capcom hadn’t hinted at a PS4 version prior to pre-order).


Miles Morales goes to work.

Insomniac / CNET screenshot

I’m still using a launch PS4 and have no plans to get any mid-generation PS5 upgrade Sony makes available, so I will squeeze a lot of value from the PS5 over its seven years of life – to play the remaining PS4 games in 4K and it will fully upgrade new generation when it really starts at the end of 2021.

To maximize the likelihood of getting games as cheap as possible, I opted for the disc drive model. Even though most of my purchases are digital, I don’t want to give Sony too much power. Even my friends sometimes give me physical games.

As for Xbox Series X, I’m still undecided. I was focused on Xbox 360, but Xbox One never had an exclusive game that made the console irresistible. Microsoft’s purchase of Bethesda certainly makes an exclusive X-series killer (Series Xclusive?) More likely, but I’ll wait and see.

Game Pass is a truly exceptional service, but my already huge backlog makes it a less appealing prospect.

Eli Blumenthal

While I was looking for both Xbox Series X and PlayStation 5 All-Digital, I’ve only pre-ordered Xbox so far. Having grown up playing all three generations of Xbox, I’ve been influenced by the PlayStation in recent years thanks to games like Spider-Man PS4 and MLB The Show.

I’m a huge sports fan and while newer titles don’t have any noticeable or game-changing improvements on the current generation, the new NBA 2K21 trailer on the next generation I was excited about what both of these new systems can offer.

The mad battle to find somewhere to pre-order a PS5 has kept me in the Xbox camp, at least for now. As someone who doesn’t have a large PlayStation disc catalog, I can’t justify shelling out an extra $ 100 for the regular PS5 (based on early reports, I might wait longer as it looks digital consoles are in less than those disc). Add in the rising costs for next-gen PlayStation controllers and core games, and I feel there are even better uses for that money than a hard drive that I almost certainly won’t be using. I don’t even remember the last time I used a disc in general: PlayStation, Xbox, Blu-ray, DVD or CD.

As for Xbox, a few factors have influenced me, including the fact that I have a Game Pass subscription, am really intrigued by xCloud, and have friends and family planning to have one. While I was thinking about the S series, with my TCL 6 series it has 4K and Dolby Vision and like Serrels the appeal of 4K gaming was enough to make me choose the bigger system.

Also, I was lucky enough to see it available on Amazon to place the order (although now it may no longer arrive on 10).

Eric Franklin

Since the release of Xbox One X I have primarily become an Xbox gamer. Microsoft’s services like Play Anywhere, xCloud, and of course Xbox Game Pass cater to my dad’s gaming needs with two young children and not much time for himself.

So I decided to pre-order both Xbox Series X for my living room and Xbox Series S for my home office.

The X series will replace my One X and the S series will double with my newly built PC on my brand new 27 inch 1440p HDR 144hz monitor. In fact, I’ll probably end up playing more games on the S series since my wife gets the first dibs on our 4K TV.

As for the games, while I can’t wait to try out some launch games like The Medium, The Ascent and The Falconeer, I’m just as interested in playing my current huge backlog of games like The Outer Worlds, Doom Eternal and Yakuza series. – I’m still in the early days of Yakuza 0, my first foray into the world of Japanese gangsters and fools – with faster load times and the ability to quickly switch between them – I get bored easily – with the Quick Resume feature.

Since Microsoft revealed these features in March, the new Xbox has taken up too much of my brain space, but it will soon have a chance to live up to my far too high expectations.

As for the PS5, I’ll probably have one eventually, but I could wait until they slim down that puppy – did you hear? It’s big.

Oscar Gonzalez

I’m usually a dual console type of gamer, but my original plan for this generation was to start with the PS5 and then eventually get my hands on an Xbox Series X. The lack of a strong, exclusive launch game – for me, it would have been Halo: Infinite – it makes Microsoft’s next-gen console a little less attractive.

That changed with the inclusion of EA Play in Games Pass and viewing Quick Resume in action. While yes, I will be able to play Games Pass titles on my Xbox One, the idea of ​​having all the games I’m playing available to play within seconds of each other is something I didn’t know I wanted. As a guy who wants to jump into different multiplayer games like Call of Duty: Warzone, Tom Clancy’s The Division 2 and even Fortnite, as well as working on various single player games like Assassin’s Creed and Far Cry, the Quick Resume is going to be the designed feature just for me.


Epic games

For that reason, I have a pre-order for PS5 and Xbox Series X. Tempted as I was to go digital this generation, the fact is that new physical games at launch, or weeks after release, tend to be on sale. The digital version no. Retailers are also quicker to lower the price of games if they fail to sell at launch, while digital titles take much longer before a significant sale.

So for me, Xbox Series X will be the Games Pass machine while the PS5 will be for Sony-released titles and other exclusives. It is the best of both worlds and at the best price.

Source link